Featured Post

On the road again — back July 6!

Back July 6!  My husband and I are taking a road trip through Utah. We're going to Zion National Park, Brice Canyon and eventually we...

Thursday, January 25, 2024

Notes on Mark: The Author and the Manuscript

I'm rereading the Gospel of Mark along with various commentaries and will be reposting episodes of my previous notes that last ran 12 years ago. I'll intersperse them with new material as it is appropriate. Kind of an old again, new again thing that we'll be doing. 

Here's a touch of background to get us started.

Pasquale Ottini
St. Mark writes his Gospel at the dictation of St. Peter


I like the fact that the Gospel of Mark was requested by the Roman Christians so they had a copy of Peter's stories.
The unanimous early tradition of the Church was that Mark's Gospel captured the narrative of the apostle Peter. According to St. Jerome, "Mark, the disciple and interpreter of Peter, write a short Gospel at the request of the brethren at Rome, embodying what he had heard Peter tell. When Peter had heard this, he approved it and published it to the churches to be read by his authority." Jerome wrote these words in A.D. 392, but the tradition went back to apostolic times. Bishop Papias of Hierapolis, who died around the year 120, used to quote an unnamed "elder" in the Church whotold him that "Mark, having become the interpreter of Peter, wrote down accurately, though not in order, whatsoever he remembered of the things said or done by Christ."

Suppose Papias heard the "elder" say this in A.D. 100, and the elder was about seventy years old. This elder would have been a mature man of around forty years when Peter was martyred i Rome in A.D. 67. Papias was a disciple of John the evangelist, and he was a friend of Polycarp. Papias' testimony, then, reaches right back to the apostles.
Even though Mark was writing based on Peter's authority, he also knew Jesus himself.
We can be sure that Mark knew Jesus Christ personally, although he was not one of the twelve Apostles: most ecclesiastical writers see in Mk 14:15-52, the episode of the young man who leaves his sheet behind him as he flees from the garden when Jesus is arrested, as Mark's own veiled signature to his Gospel, since only he refers to this episode. If this were the only reference it would be ambiguous, but it is supported by other circumstantial evidence: Mark was the son of Mary, apparently a well-to-do widow, in whose house in Jerusalem the first Christians used to gather (Acts 12:12). An early Christian text states that this was the same house as the Cenacle, where our Lord celebrated the Last Supper and instituted the Holy Eucharist. It also seems probably that the Garden of Olives belonged to this same Mary; which would explain Mark's presence there.
More interesting, historical stuff about the book itself.
There is a very interesting thing about Mark's gospel. In its original form it stops at Mark 16:8. We know that for two reasons. First, the verses which follow (Mark 16:9-20) are not in any of the great early manuscripts; only later and inferior manuscripts contain them. Second, the style of the Greek is so different that they cannot have been written by the same person as wrote the rest of the gospel.

But the gospel cannot have been meant to stop at Mark 16:8. What then happened? It may be that Mark died, perhaps even suffered martyrdom, before he could complete his gospel. More likely, it may be that at one time only one copy of the gospel remained, and that a copy in which the last part of the roll on which it was written had got torn off. There was a time when the church did not much use Mark, preferring Matthew and Luke. It may well be that Mark's gospel was so neglected that all copies except for a mutilated one were lost. If that is so we were within an ace of losing the gospel which in many ways is the most important of all.
The Gospel of Mark
(The Daily Bible Series*, rev. ed.;
)
* Not a Catholic source and one which can have a wonky theology at times, but Barclay was renowned for his authority on life in ancient times and that information is sound.

UPDATE (from 2012)
I have been contacted by a gentleman who begs me to stop quoting Barclay's comment that Mark 16:9-20 is not in any of the early great manuscripts.

Therefore, I turned to Mary Healy's excellent Catholic Commentary on Sacred Scripture to see what she said. Here we go, sports fans!
Verses 9-20, commonly called the Longer Ending, do not appear in the earliest manuscripts of the Gospel. Scholars are virtually unanimous in holding that these verses were not written by Mark but by a Christian of the late first or early second century who sought to fill out the abrupt ending of verse 8. (Footnote: a few ancient and medieval manuscripts of Mark insert other brief endings, which the Church does not accept as canonical.) Yet the Church accepts this addendum as part of the canon of inspired Scripture. The Holy Spirit's gift of inspiration is not limited to the original writer, but encompasses each biblical book in its final edited form.

The author of the Longer Ending was apparently familiar with all four Gospels (or with the oral testimonies on which they were based), and compiled these verses from the resurrection accounts in Matthew, Luke and John. ...

 ===== 

The Snowball

The Snowball, Otto Seitz

Tuesday, January 23, 2024

The Expressive Voice of the Longhorn

"No wild animal, or domestic either, has as many vocal tones as the Longhorn. In comparison, the bulls and cows of highly bred varieties of cattle are voiceless. The cow of the Longhorns has one moo for her newborn calf, another for when it is older, one to tell it come to her side and another to tell it to stay hidden in the tall grass. Moved by amatory feelings, she has a low, audible breath of yearning. In anger, she can run a gamut. If her calf has died or otherwise been taken from her, she seems to be turning her insides out into long, sharp, agonizing bawls. I have heard steers make similar sounds. They seemed to be in the utmost agony of something so poignant to them that the utterance meant more than life and would be willingly paid for by death."
J. Frank Dobie, "The Longhorns," 1941
Photo and quote via Traces of Texas

Psalm 40 — Waiting Patiently

During the attack, as you suffer the afflictions and wish to learn the advantage of steadfast patience, sing Psalm 40.
Athanasius, On the Interpretation of the Psalms

This one has been long regarded as praise and patience as one waits for an answer to prayer. Peter Kreeft points out that waiting is the first step in finding out what God wants from us.

"I have waited, waited for the Lord." The Psalmist says it twice because waiting always feels too long and tries our patience. But we must never, never, never, never, never give up. because God will always respond.

The second thing the Psalmist tells us is what God does in response to our waiting for him: he "heard my cry." Waiting is a "cry," a cry from the heart. Waiting is an active, passionate, and painful thing, not a passive, easy, comfortable thing. If we wait for God in this way, he will always hear us and answer us. And in answering us, the Psalmist says, he "stooped toward me," as a tall adult stoops to talk to a tiny child. He humbled himself. He came down to our level, since we cannot raise ourselves up to his level by ourselves.

Food for the Soul, Year C, Second Sunday in Ordinary Time

Look at this image to see under just what conditions the psalmist is imagined patiently waiting. Yikes!!!! But it does go along with what the psalm tells us.

There are two kinds of patience being mentioned here. The first is patient endurance for a long time. The second is enduring hope and expectation that doesn't fade. God doesn't always act quickly but He's worth waiting for.

"I waited patiently for the Lord"
Les Très Riches Heures du duc de Berry, Musée Condé

This is lengthy but I was fascinated by all the possibilities that the language indicates. All of these kinds of muck and mire are familiar. All make us long even more for a secure rock with firm footing.

Stuck in the Muck
The psalmist is seeking deliverance from sin, so it is interesting to see how its consequences are described as being mired down in a slippery place, with no secure footing or ability to escape. Several images are attached to the vocabulary used here. (1) One appears to refer to the clay pounded out into a smooth surface in building village streets. While in most circumstances this must have provided a relatively hard surface, on occasions of rain or perhaps the spilling of blood in battle, the clay could become slippery and muddy (cf. Zech. 10:5).

(2) A second image connected with the slippery mire is the shifty sediments of the sea bed. Isaish 57:20 describes the restless sea that tosses up slimy seaweed and mud. Similarly, Psalm 69:14 describes the desperate plight of one who is sinking into the mire while the sea waves crash over him.

(3) The final image associated with slippery mud refers to the sediment left in the bottom of an abandoned cistern or pit. Jeremiah 38:6 describes the circumstances in which the prophet was abandoned to die by his enemies in a cistern having "no water in it, only mus, and Jeremiah sank down into the mud." When the kind learned of Jeremiah's fate, he sent men with ropes to draw him up out of the muck and mire of the pit. Similarly Joseph's brother threw him into an empty cistern before drawing him out in order to sell him to passing Midianites (Gen. 37:19-28). Lamentations 3:53 describes the poet being thrown into a cistern and left to die while the "waters closed over my head." Apparently these accounts draw on a common practice of using cisterns for imprisonment. ...
Psalms Volume 1 (The NIV Application Commentary)

An index of psalm posts is here.

Monday, January 22, 2024

Polycarp's Zinger

For more than half a century Polycarp devoted himself to teaching sound doctrine and opposing heresy. Once on a visit to rome he had snubbed the heretic Marcion. "Don't you know who I am, Polycarp?" he asked. "Oh yes," said the saint, "I know the firstborn of Satan when I see him."
Bert Ghezzi, The Voices of the Saints
I wish I was that quick with a witty quip.

Evening Elegance: Birch Ambiance

Evening Elegance: Birch Ambiance, Remo Savisaar
This reminds me of growing up in Kansas and Missouri where winter weather gave us gorgeous snow covered trees.

Friday, January 19, 2024

Hot Pepper Popcorn

Once again we have the playoffs coming and once again I bring you this popcorn that will delight anyone who enjoys a little spice with their popcorn crunch. Get the recipe for Hot Pepper Popcorn at Meanwhile, Back in the Kitchen.

Dream During the Dance

Dream During the Dance (Ensueño durante el baile)
Rogelio de Egusquiza
Click on the image to see the details close up. This is just beautiful work and, of course, I'm always a sucker for a gorgeously painted gown.

Genesis and cell phones

To read Genesis for its views about evolutionary theories is like reading Genesis for its views about cell phones.
Dr. Chrostopher Kaczor,
Word on Fire Bibel: The Pentateuch
That's just so spot on it made me laugh out loud. What a perfect comparison to get the point across.

Thursday, January 18, 2024

Lectio Divina — Fiction

Notice that the apostles’ first and most important duty was simply to “be with him*”—to “waste time” in the presence of Jesus, loving him and being loved by him, learning his ways, letting their hearts become more and more aligned with his.
Mary Healy, The Word Among Us, Oct. 2022
==========
My job was just to spend twenty minutes with scripture: reading, thinking, and praying as I chose; the fireworks were up to God.
Leah Libresco, Arriving at Amen
Stained glass of the Holy Spirit as a dove
The Holy Spirit helps us pray.

There can be an internal pressure to our prayer time, as if God is grading us on how well we do. In actuality as long as we’re there praying, however we choose to do it, then we’re doing it right. Just the doing of it, the hanging out, our presence is what is required. God will do the rest. 

I want to know Jesus as well as the disciples did. 

In my case, I continually return to lectio divina, which means divine reading. It's a slow, contemplative reading, usually of the Bible. We read, listening for the murmur of God, and contemplate what we find. Here's an article which explains it well.

In my case, God has spoken to me through literature since I became aware that he was a real person. (That's another story.) Last year I began including fiction in my lectio divina. My prayer time became a time that I couldn't wait for. After all, who doesn't love reading a good story and talking it over with a friend?

 I pick fiction that I know is inspirational on some level. Then I read for around 15-20 minutes. I read the book, a chapter a day if possible, from cover to cover. As things strike me, I will stop to appreciate the truth I've just realized. These are my moments to share with Jesus. It can be incredibly fruitful. And sometimes there is nothing but reading the story. That's how prayer goes.  

I began by reading The Lord of the Rings during Lent, It was unbelievably powerful. I went on to read In This House of Brede, The Feast, A Little Princess, Death Comes for the Archbishop, and The Hobbit. Occasionally I will read nonfiction but it is usually telling a story — The Hiding Place, A Song for Nagasaki, and The Smile of a Ragpicker. 

I also read A Beginner's Guide to Dante's Divine Comedy by Jason M. Baxter. It was a sort of a cheat because I really wanted to reread Dante but wasn't quite ready to dive in again. Because it was delving into Dante, it was a rich source of inspiration. This year, might be the Divine Comedy year.

Every book was chosen in the service of hanging out and reading something that captured my interest as a point of conversation with Jesus. There's a real sense of anticipation when my afternoon prayer time comes up now. And if I'm not feeling so eager, it is not a hardship to pick up a book I enjoy. I am soon pulled back into the reading (and conversation) I love so well.

* He appointed twelve, to be with him (Mark 3:14). 

Wednesday, January 17, 2024

Bookish Diversions: Shhh! Happens

 From one of my favorite spots on the internet, Joel Miller at Miller's Book Reviews tells us a lot of things about libraries, including this which made me very happy:

Younger Americans love libraries. Millennials and Gen Zers spend time at their local library more frequently than their elders. “54% of Gen Zers and millennials trekk[ed] to their local library in 2022,” say Portland State University professors Kathi Inman Berens and Rachel Noorda, compared to 45 percent of Gen Xers and 43 percent of boomers.

One reason? While the younger generations spend a lot of time on digital devices engaging social media, they prefer print over digital or audio when it comes to books and, according to Berens and Noorda’s data, average about two print books a month. “Gen Zers and millennials still see libraries as a kind of oasis,” they say, “a place where doomscrolling and information overload can be quieted, if temporarily.“
This leads to a lot of interesting things including that libraries all over the world serve as "valued third places." Get it all at the link.

Altar Boy

Vincenzo Irolli, Altar Boy
via I Am A Child
Isn't this curious scamp adorable? Check the link in the caption for many more Vincenzo Irolli paintings. I'd never heard of that artist before but found much of his work captivating.

Gunpowder and books

Gunpowder destroys itself along with its victim, while a book can keep on exploding for centuries.
Christopher Morley, The Haunted Bookshop
Amen, amen!

Tuesday, January 16, 2024

Sources for Gospel of Mark Bible Study

I began reading The Memoirs of St. Peter, a new translation of Mark, and remembered these notes. Heavens to Betsy! The last time we looked at the Gospel of Mark together it was 2012!

We're way past time to take a second look at some of the things that bring Mark alive for me. Here are my favorite resources. I may not quote all of these, but I'll have looked through them and over the years they have added to my overall knowledge.

Mark the Evangelist by Il Pordenone

The Memoirs of St. Peter: A New Translation of the Gospel According to Mark
Mark Pakaluk’s goal is to restore the freshness and realism feel of the text as originally written by Mark. He's interested in Mark's Gospel as being a first-hand account told by St. Peter of what it was like to live with Christ for three years. He also has insightful commentary which helps us feel "you are there."
 
The Navarre Bible: Mark
The Navarre commentaries are consistently excellent and have a lot of thoughts from Church Fathers, Popes, saints, and the Catechism. They add wisdom from the 2,000 years of Church contemplation on scripture since Jesus.

Life Application Study Bible: New International Version
This Protestant Bible is an interesting resource. The footnotes are fresh, interesting, and a good resource for historical questions such as how threshing was done when Ruth met Boaz for example. They also have maps and occasional one page essays about main figures of the Bible. There is a tendency to ask questions at the end of commentary such as, "Do you listen to God like this person, etc.?" which I find rather annoying but they may not strike everyone that way. I would advise the NIV version as I have been told that translation is more accurate than the New Living Translation.

Catholic Commentary on Sacred Scripture: The Gospel of Mark
The structure is such that you are generally covering just a little scripture at a time. Each reading is followed with cross references to the Old Testament, New Testament, Catechism, and Liturgy. These are followed by the commentary, in which words from the scripture reading are bold whenever they are used. Although I saw some people complaining about that practice, I found it useful. Sometimes a bold word would make me suddenly pay attention and go back to the scripture, thinking, "Did it really say that? Why haven't I ever noticed before?"

There are also a few maps, occasional photos when they'd be helpful, and sidebar boxes with Biblical background and living tradition (Catechism, Fathers of the Church, saints) information that enriches understanding.

In Conversation with God by Francis Fernandez
A daily devotional that follows the daily Mass readings. Topics range from the sacraments and virtues to family interaction and friendship. The sensible and down-to-earth writing is enhanced by quotes from saints, Church Fathers, popes, cross-references with other scripture than in the day's readings, Church documents, etc. I've been using this for 20 years off and on.  Full review here.

The Word on Fire Bible: The Gospels
From the Word on Fire ministries headed by Bishop Robert Barron, this is a commentary bible loaded with observations from the Church Fathers, newer Catholic writers like Fulton Sheen and G.K. Chesterton, and Bishop Barron himself. The primary purpose is evangelization of those not affiliated with organization or Christianity and poses the question throughout of "Who is God? and "Who is Jesus Christ?"

Opening the Scripture series: Bringing the Gospel of Matthew to Life
This is the one that I used for my first Gospel of Matthew series of posts, way back in 2008. It's still good. Read my full review here.

Ignatius Mark Study Bible
This has since been gathered into the Ignatius Study New Testament by Scott Hahn and Curtis Mitch. I already had it in this individual little book. The commentary is excellent, as one would expect.

Mark: a Devotional Commentary
Practical and easy to use. From Word Among Us but also with a Kindle version.

Food for the Soul
In his inimitable style, Kreeft offers reflections on each of the Sunday Mass readings, excepting the psalms (which I wish he'd included). These amount to a series of mini-homilies on each reading and I like them a lot so far. My review is here.

The Word of the Lord
Biblical scholar Dr. John Bergsma provides commentary on each Sunday's selection of readings. Whether you are a homilist seeking insight into the meaning of difficult scriptural passages or a Catholic desiring a deepened understanding of the readings you hear at Mass, The Word of the Lord series is an invaluable guide. My review is here.

The Daily Study Bible Series — The Gospel of Mark, Revised Edition
I'm a real fan of William Barclay's commentaries on the New Testament books. Barclay's strengths are his phenomenal knowledge of the Greek language, the Jewish culture and religion, and the Roman occupation during the New Testament era. He is wonderful at conveying this knowledge in a way that simple and easily understandable. He puts it in context so that you can understand what events meant to the people to whom Jesus spoke to 2,000 years ago.

However, I have to always include this caveat when mentioning William Barclay ... his theology can be very wonky if you are Catholic. For example, his commentary on the gospels with nativity stories include a number of reasons Jesus' virgin birth didn't necessarily have to be virgin. Sorry. That's really nonnegotiable. He also often includes pointed commentary about why Roman Catholic teachings are wrong. So there's that ...

But if one reads with a knowledgeable eye, Barclay's work is really wonderful.

NOTE: the recently revised versions (1990s and beyond) have been heavily edited to be more politically correct. I'm not sure what that has done to Barclay's original work so I just go with the second revision, done under Barclay's eye. I'm not so thin skinned that I can't stand a little old fashionedness.

Snow balls

Snow balls, Bertha Lum. Via J.R.'s Art Place.
I can feel how much fun they're having! We actually got a little snow yesterday. It was too powdery to do much with but the little kids still had fun trying.

Monday, January 15, 2024

Road Tripping in Turkey


EatingAsia has a fascinating piece called Road Tripping in Turkey, or How to Self-Drive and Survive. It also has some gorgeous photography, as anyone who hangs out there much would expect. In fact, I couldn't resist sharing an extra photo. The blog hasn't been active for a while but I still like to swing by and refresh myself with the beautiful images.

When we're arguing with the past ...

When we're arguing with the past, we're really arguing with the present.
That is so true it hardly seems worth saying, but when you look at our cultural state with it in mind I don't think it is being said enough.

Friday, January 12, 2024

A Duel of Storytelling

You ever think about how wild it is that you humans just tell each other stories about your day? Like you'll be on the phone for forty-five minutes with a customer service rep, and then later someone will ask you about your day and you'll be like "I was on the phone forever with customer service," and they'll just be waiting to tell you about a time they were on the phone with customer service. It's like a duel of storytelling, and y'all do it all the time!
Alexander Kane, Dragon Heist

Storytelling animals, that's us! I love that we're so hardwired for it.

Thursday, January 11, 2024

Tuna Risotto

Tuna Risotto is one of the first recipes I ever shared at Meanwhile, Back in the Kitchen. Despite the canned tuna, it really is an Italian recipe. Easy. Perfect for a meatless Friday or a quick weekday meal. Try it!

Arsène Lupin, a gentleman thief and master of disguise

André Brulé as Arsène Lupin, a gentleman thief and master of disguise

 

Tuesday, January 9, 2024

2023 — Best of Re-Viewing

How long's it been since you rewatched these? Pardner, that's too long.

My top picks from last year. In no particular order.

Prem Ratan Dhan Payo
A fun, frothy take on The Prisoner of Zenda.
(My review here.)

Manhattan Murder Mystery
A screwball comedy that combines a tightly-plotted mystery with an examination of comfortable, middle-aged marriage.
Radio Days
Woody Allen's love letter to radio centered around a love of family that shines through the humor and nostalgia.

Everyone Says I Love You
Woody Allen's love letter to musicals, Hollywood love stories, and New York all wrapped up in the tale of a wealthy family's year told as a musical.
 
Jodhaa Akbar
Along the lines of Cecil B. DeMille, this epic tale is about the romance between Akbar the Great and princess Jodhaa which will bring together the divided people of India into one people.

Fahrenheit 451
In a future a "fireman" is the one who burns any books that are found. What happens when a fireman learns to read and value the ideas that he finds in books? Both the book and the movie are works of genius.

Amelie
It's been at least a decade since I watched this and it was really delightful experiencing it again as if for the first time. Quirky, but not too quirky. A lot of heart and purity but not sappy. And a celebration of the importance of the little things in life.

Cinderella (2015)
The best of the live-action Disney remakes because they stuck to the story without trying to improve it for modern values. I was especially impressed with the moral underpinning and the way the evil stepmother's story subtly intertwines with Cinderella's by the end.

Broadway Danny Rose
What I forgot, or hadn't noticed the first time around, was the sheer humanity exhibited by Woody Allen and Mia Farrow at the end as their characters reach crisis and must deal with it.
Mulan (1998)
A classic that I took my kids to see when it came out. Having seen the live-action Mulan made me realize how much the songs contribute to this movie. Probably the last of the great movies from Disney's second Golden Age.

Monday, January 8, 2024

2023 — Best of Rereading

How long's it been since you reread these? Pardner, that's too long.

My top picks from last year. In no particular order.


A Song for Nagasaki
by Paul Glynn
The biography of Takashi Nagai, a young Catholic Japanese doctor who lived through the bombing of Nagasaki and became an inspiration for spiritual healing for his people. Paul Glynn combines vivid descriptions, character insights, and just enough Japanese history so that we have context. 
(My review here.)

War for the Oaks
by Emma Bull
Rich urban fantasy that pulls the reader into the world of Emma Bull's making. We learn about champions, love, truth, honor ... and, of course, musicians. 

West of Eden
by Harry Harrison
What if the dinosaurs had survived to evolve intelligent life? This is an exciting adventure in a world where the descendants of the dinosaurs struggle with a clan of humans in a battle for survival.
(My review here.)

Aunt Dimity's Death
by Nancy Atherton
Lori thought that Aunt Dimity was a character her mother invented for charming bedtime stories. Until she found that the real Aunt Dimity just died, leaving her an inheritance. A cozy mystery that is a fairy tale, ghost story and mystery.
(My review here.)

The Blue Sword
by Robin McKinley 
This is the story of Corlath, golden-eyed king of the Free Hillfolk. And this is the story of Harry Crewe, the Homelander orphan girl who became King's Rider, and heir to the Blue Sword. And this is the song of the kelar of the Hillfolk, the magic of the blood, the weaver of destinies...
A near-perfect fantasy. Just reading the description makes me want to pick it up again.

The Unexpected Mrs. Pollifax
by Dorothy Gilman
When the elderly Mrs. Pollifax's doctor recommends she tries something new that she's always wanted to do, she applies at the CIA to be a spy. Thanks to a misunderstanding, she's sent on a courier mission and winds up in the middle of something dangerous where her inexperience leads to a sort of inspired mayhem that throws the bad guys off kilter.
(My review here.)


Christy
by Catherine Marshall
A fascinating story about people in the Smoky Mountains in 1912 cut off from any outside civilization except for a few people who came in to try to help their poverty stricken situation. Including the 19-year-old young woman, Christy, who comes to teach the children. She is naive and from a well-to-do background so she's completely unprepared for what she finds. Also extremely inspirational.


The Hiding Place
by Corrie ten Boom
Sheltered spinster, Corrie Ten Boom is 50 years old when the Nazis invade Holland. She and her family shelter Jews targeted by the Nazis and when they are caught, they are sent to prison and eventually concentration camps. This sounds gloomy and like a familiar story. It is not. Every Christian should read this book. Simply fantastic.
(My review here.)

Friday, January 5, 2024

Best of 2023 — Podcasts

 My top picks from podcasts I discovered last year. As always, they may be old, but my listening was brand new in 2023. In no particular order. Links are in the podcast name.

Fr. Mike Schmitz guides you through the entire Catechism of the Catholic Church in 365 episodes, providing explanation, insight, and encouragement along the way.
Like the Bible in a Year podcast, this is chock full of Father Mike Schmitz's explanations that help us see how the Catechism applies to everyday life. He doesn't dodge the touchy issues, because the Catechism doesn't. But his explanations help to explain the logic and love that is behind all the Church's teachings. I have thoroughly enjoyed this one.
Podcaster Erik Rostad started Books of Titans as an experiment to discover how to read more books and remember what I read. I enjoyed the past episodes I tried as he was really good at pulling out big ideas from each book and often would find them connecting to other books in unexpected ways. 

In 2023 he began a project to read the Great Books and see the wisdom of the ages and the cultural influence they have imparted. Not only has Erik been discussing the ancient books but he has paired them with more modern works which help give context. Erik is a thoughtful reader and it is fascinating to hear him go through these books. His goal is to finish by 2030. Read more about that project here.

How to Eat an Elephant
A Little Book Club for Large Books
 

Of course, as the saying goes, you eat an elephant one bite at a time. Podcasters Ian, Emily, and Megan do a great job of reading five chapters a week and looking at them indepth. So far they've read War and Peace and Les Miserables. It's thanks to their discussions that I made it halfway through War and Peace last year before deciding I'd read as much as I needed to and dropping the book. It wasn't them, it was just that I'd read all I needed to of War and Peace. However, they are engaging and thoughtful and I'll be on board the next time they pick up a long read that is on my list.

Anupama Chopra, founder & editor of Film Companion, is a film critic, television anchor and book author. She has been writing about Bollywood since 1993. Here you can find all of her reviews for movies from across the globe.
I discovered this when browsing through Evergreen Podcasts listings. Anupama Chopra gives just the succinct yet personal reviews of new Indian films that help me know whether or not to put movies on my list. So far, her tastes and ours match up very well. 

Thursday, January 4, 2024

Best of 2023 — TV

 Here are my top picks from our year of TV viewing. Our television viewing was not extensive but we discovered some that were pure gold. In no particular order.

I began my "Best of" lists way back in 2008. To see them, check the label cloud in the sidebar under "Best of ..." 

 
 

2023 BEST TV

The Romantics documentary series
The legacy of Yash Chopra and Yash Raj Films

A really excellent documentary. Well edited, conceived and executed. This series is one that Indians will enjoy and that true film fans will appreciate. Other than that, only people like us — a true minority of Indian film lovers who are not ourselves Indian — will appreciate.


Tale of the Nine Tailed

Lee Yeon is a mythical nine tailed fox in this fun and exciting roller coaster of a K-drama. He works on earth for the the gods' Department of Immigration of Life After Death — hunting down mythical beings who kill humans. A lovely television producer, Nam Ji-Ah, whose show investigates the supernatural, suspects that he is involved in a murder case. She investigates him and he investigates her. Ji-Ah's looking for her long lost parents and Yeong's on the lookout for the reincarnation of his lost love. Naturally they will work together. Just as naturally, nothing is as it appears on the surface.

If you like this then go watch Tale of the Nine Tailed 1938 which is the sequel (prequel). Although not quite as good as this, it is a lot of fun and still quite good.


Law School

Yang Jong-hoon, a prosecutor-turned-professor, teaches criminal law at a prestigious law school. He and his first-year law students get involved in an unprecedented case during a mock trial. During a mock trial class, the supervising professor is found murdered and Professor Yang is arrested as the main suspect. Showing on Netflix.

There was a refreshing lack of romance, aside from the occasional glance sent from one student to another while they weren't looking. This was a straight up drama that's wildly intricate and inventive in the plot's twists and turns. Somehow it had plenty of drama without being emotionally over-the-top, which we appreciated too.


Only Murders in the Building
Season 3

If you've watched the first two seasons then you know what to expect. If not, please go find this series and begin with season one. I mention it because we were impressed with the way the show followed the new theme (murder at an off-Broadway musical) and held true to all the things that made it great in the first two seasons. We're looking forward to season 4.

Wellington Paranormal

Sergeant Ruawai Maaka of the Wellington Police enlists the aid of Officers Minogue and O'Leary to tackle paranormal events in New Zealand's capital city. The mockumentary follows these kiwi cops as they investigate cases such as the demon possession of a teenager, a noise complaint at a haunted house and a blood bank robbery.
Just plain fun.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds

Follows Captain Christopher Pike and the crew of the starship Enterprise in the 23rd century as they explore new worlds and carry out missions throughout the galaxy during the decade before Star Trek: The Original Series.

We enjoyed this quite a lot. It was an intriguing blend of faithfulness to the Star Trek sensibilities while containing character development and modern ideas.

Wednesday, January 3, 2024

Best of 2023 — Movies

 Here are my top picks from our year of viewing. We watched  around 125 movies last year.  

As always, the movies may be old, but my viewing was brand new in 2023. In no particular order.

I began my "Best of" lists way back in 2008. To see them, check the label cloud in the sidebar under "Best of ..."


2023 BEST MOVIES

Grand Hotel

The first Hollywood all-star epic with a lot of high-powered stars of the 1930s. We watched it because we were working our way through the Oscar winner/nominees for 1923. This is the movie where Greta Garbo's famous "I want to be alone" line originated. We were surprised at how much we enjoyed this very good movie which can hold its own against stories of today.

Bholaa

This is a big action movie with lots of great stunts and acting from some top Bollywood stars. Moreover it was a compelling story with clearly drawn characters, excellent acting, clever twists, stylish choreography and imagery, and over-the-top action very well done.

Confess, Fletch
Honor Among Thieves
Game Night

These are three movies whose only goal is to entertain. There have been precious few of those lately from Hollywood so we were thrilled to find them. Each is silly in its own way, but each one is fun in just the right way.

Kantara

Shiva is a tribal vagabond who lives with his mother in a tiny forest village. He avoids participation in the traditional worship ceremonies due to an unforgettable childhood incident. He is happy loafing around with his friends and doing petty jobs for his landlord. When forest officer Murali enters the scene, it gives a fresh dimension to the man-vs-nature fight. Can Shiva save the forest from Murali?

Father Stu

This is that rare find, a well done Christian movie. Usually we avoid faith based films like the plague because  but we gave this a chance because we were intrigued not only by the basic story but by Mark Wahlberg's dedication to getting it produced. Our faith was well rewarded.

Rocky Aur Rani Kii Prem Kahaani
(Rocky and Rani's Love Story)

Rocky is a loud, showy Punjabi from a family who made their fortune making laddoos (sweets). Rani is a sophisticated, stylish television personality from a Bengali family. Brought together by a fluke because each loves their grandparents, they fall in love. This romantic comedy is a three-hour long, dance loaded, romance loaded movie that leaves you smiling. It's been described as "delicious eye candy with a rebellious core" and nothing could be truer. (My review here.)

 

Kathal — A Jackfruit Mystery

We all really loved this movie which follows Inspector Mahima Basor and her team as they pursue the ridiculous case of two stolen jackfruits. Everyone realizes it is a waste of resources but no one will say no to the politician. As you might expect there is a fair amount of humor but it is usually gentle and understated, which can be a rarity in Indian movies.

(My review here.)


Brochevarevarura
(Who Shall Save the Day?)

This story has the framework of an aspiring scriptwriter who is telling the story to an actress who he hopes to interest in starring in the film he's writing. The film pops in and out of this framework and it is interesting to see how the story can subtly change going forward based on the actress's questions or comments. Halfway through the film a plot twist popped up that left us astounded and intrigued. This made all the difference.

Mission Impossible: Dead Reckoning, part 1

We closed out the year with the latest Mission Impossible movie. These are always fun because they are so reliable. You know you are getting real entertainment along with a dose of uncompromising view of good versus evil, right versus wrong. Ethan Hunt (Tom Cruise) is on the right side, albeit having to overcome flaws along the way. I especially enjoyed the many flashes of humor throughout. We thoroughly enjoyed this movie and can't wait for part 2.

Tuesday, January 2, 2024

Best of 2023 — Reading

 My top picks from the over 120 books I read last year.

You may find old books here but if they're on this list, then they were new to me! In no particular order.

Note: I've been doing this since 2008 — check the label cloud in the sidebar for "Best of" to see other lists.

2023 BEST BOOKS

Owls Hoot in the Daytime and Other Omens

by Manly Wade Wellman
John's guitar has silver strings and with that, songs, and sometimes a silver quarter he battles evil. We are never in doubt that John will win. The charm comes in the Appalachian flavor and the imaginative nature of the predicaments faced.
(Full review here.)

Markmaker

by Mary Jessica Woods
Mariikel is a talented markmaker in a society where people's marks (tattoos) are the record of their lives. When he is ordered to put an exile mark on someone who he thinks isn't guilty it leads to an exciting story that also examines conscience, honor, truth, family, history, and politics.

Winters in the World:
A Journey Through the Anglo-Saxon Year

by Eleanor Parker
Eleanor Parker weaves a tapestry of poetry, literature, history, religion, and language to go through the seasons and practices of the Anglo-Saxon year. The result is a masterpiece that gave me a real sense of connection with the people of long ago and a deep appreciation with the sacred cycle of time both then and now. This might be my favorite book of the year.

The Wolf-Leader

by Alexandre Dumas
This Faustian tale infuses the hijinks of The Three Musketeers into a supernatural story with a moral center. A little-known Dumas story that is really delightful.

30 Days with Married Saints

by Kent and Caitlin Lasnoski
Each day contains vivid portraits of heroically virtuous married saints as well as prayers, moving reflections, questions, and practical suggestions to enrich your marriage and inspire you and your spouse on your journey of sanctity. Really inspiring.

What Monstrous Gods

by Rosamund Hodge
Rosamund Hodge is a fantasy writer whose begins, however tangentially, with a well-known fairy tale and then takes imaginative leaps into something completely original and breath-taking. In this case it begins with what happens when Sleeping Beauty awakens. This book will come out in 2024 and I'm looking forward to having my own hardback copy to reread.

Before the Coffee Gets Cold

by Toshikazu Kawaguchi
A wonderful, charming tale of four people who go to an obscure cafe which is rumored to make time travel possible. The rules are strict, the time is very limited, and it seems impossible that they could accomplish much. Simple but magical.

Third Eye

by Felicia Day
What happens when The Chosen One fails to defeat the ultimate villain and winds up reading tarot cards in a seedy part of San Francisco? Therein lies the fun as Felicia Day combines fantasy quest tropes in a way that is hilarious and also fulfilling. Just plain fun.

Starter Villain

by John Scalzi
When Charlie's long-lost uncle Jake dies he realizes that Jake wasn't just a pay-garage tycoon, but a super villain. The first hint? When he inherits an island complete with a volcano lair. Another that is just plain fun.

Surprised by Oxford

 by Carolyn Weber
Halfway through I was recommending it to every Christian I know. Having finished it, I am still doing so.

Friday, December 29, 2023

The Miracle Club


In 1967 three women from a small Irish town dream of winning a pilgrimage to Lourdes, a place of miracles. An old acquaintance surfaces just before they leave and, despite hard feelings from long ago, joins the pilgrimage. They are each seeking a miracle. 

This movie got mixed reviews and we were going to skip it until a trusted friend said that she liked it and it had some good funny bits. So we went ahead and it was a pleasant surprise. It was solidly directed and expertly acted with an underlying look at what you are expecting when you go looking for a miracle.  

I especially appreciated how understated the story was. There were many opportunities for an impassioned explanation of an old wrong but usually we were given small hints or implications from an actress's stillness or slight change in posture. This left the story feeling more real and drew us in.

The weakest link was the priest who didn't actually believe in anything except the need to believe. That was a typically weak, modern presentation of a priest. Luckily he wasn't in the movie very much. The story focuses solidly on the four women and it really is a women's movie. 

Recommended even for those who, like me, don't want to see a "women's movie."

Wednesday, December 27, 2023

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds


Star Trek: Strange New Worlds follows Captain Christopher Pike and the crew of the starship Enterprise in the 23rd century as they explore new worlds and carry out missions throughout the galaxy during the decade before Star Trek: The Original Series.

Although I watched many of the Star Trek series as they came out, later ones haven't really been my cup of tea. However, I was intrigued after two trusted sources recommended this prequel to the original series featuring Captain Pike and several other regular characters from the original series. 

We enjoyed this quite a lot. It was an intriguing blend of faithfulness to the Star Trek sensibilities while containing character development and modern ideas. Generally this worked out well although our family didn't like the Dr. M'Benga arc with his child. While trying not to spoil anything, I will add that Catholics will understand our basic objections and note the unapologetic storyline here. It's nothing to avoid but I did want to mention that some modern elements just can't be avoided in current television.

However, generally thumbs up and we super duper loved the final episode.

My sources tell me that season two was terrible but the season ending was so satisfying that we are quite content to let our exploration stop here. If you're a Trek fan definitely try season one.

Friday, December 22, 2023

Jesse Tree - Day 16 - Jonah

This year we have the shortest possible time between the first Advent Sunday and Christmas. That means we won't be seeing a lot of the Jesse Tree entries. And I discovered that I should've switched to the O Antiphons on the 17th. Ah well, I told you this was going to be idiosyncratic!

We'll end this year with Jonah, who is a good example of what NOT to do (run away when God gives you a task) and what to do (pray when you're in the belly of a huge fish).

======

I last published these Jesse Tree posts in 2019. I want to revisit them this Advent so you're coming along for the ride!

The Jesse Tree helps us prepare for Christ's coming by studying His roots and Salvation History. 

Jesse Trees follow the same general outline but I've found they are widely varied in some of the details. Some may have one day for Moses, others may spend 4 days on different aspects of his life. I'll be following the basic outline but, therefore, using my own discretion in a few spots.


Day 16: Jonah

Symbols: whale

Jonah and the Whale
As a friend of mine once said, "Jonah is the comedy book in the Bible." It's 4 chapters long, it's an action story, and it's very funny. What's not to like?

The Church Fathers often compare Jonah's three days in the fish to Christ's three days in the tomb. I myself love the fact that Jonah is so busy running from God. Been there. Done that. Luckily without any huge fish being involved.

And I love the fact that God is so funny when he is poking Jonah at the end of the book. He cares enough to save the Ninevites who were the most hated people of their time. And he cares about each one individually, such as Jonah.

God Talks to Jonah

Thursday, December 21, 2023

TV You Might Have Missed 7 — Wellington Paranormal


Sergeant Ruawai Maaka of the Wellington Police enlists the aid of Officers Minogue and O'Leary to tackle paranormal events in New Zealand's capital city. The mockumentary follows these kiwi cops as they investigate cases such as the demon possession of a teenager, a noise complaint at a haunted house and a blood bank robbery.

What the description above misses is that the whole thing is done with deadpan humor as the cops clearly don't have the faintest idea what "paranormal" involves. They don't believe in ghosts, think that a wolf in jeans is just like dressed up dogs on YouTube, and are baffled by crop circles.

Partway through the first episode I felt echoes of Flight of the Conchords and, sure enough, Jermaine Clement is a creator. I haven't seen What We Do in the Shadows, having been assured by my girls that it is way too gory for me, but this is a spin-off of that, which makes sense.

Jesse Tree - Day 15: Elijah

I last published these Jesse Tree posts in 2019. I want to revisit them this Advent so you're coming along for the ride!

The Jesse Tree helps us prepare for Christ's coming by studying His roots and Salvation History. 

Jesse Trees follow the same general outline but I've found they are widely varied in some of the details. Some may have one day for Moses, others may spend 4 days on different aspects of his life. I'll be following the basic outline but, therefore, using my own discretion in a few spots.

Day 15: Elijah

Symbols: stone altar

Elijah and the priests of Baal
We all have a few vague pictures of Elijah. For one thing, he shows up during Christ's transfiguration so we should pay a bit of attention when he comes up in the Jesse Tree. Usually it is because he stands up for God before the priests of Ba'al and wins hands-down (for God is on his side). It is a spectacular showdown and if you aren't familiar with it, I encourage you to read about it.

Some may think of the ravens feeding him in the wilderness. I myself always remember the pagan woman whose grain and oil never ran out, even though there was a famine, because Elijah was boarding with her. And whose son he raised from the dead.

The Elijah story that speaks to my heart most, though, is one that I suspect we all relate to. Elijah is on the run from the Israelite leaders who want to kill him. He is weary and heart-sick and wants to give up. And God comes to speak to him.
And behold, the LORD passed by, and a great and strong wind rent the mountains, and broke in pieces the rocks before the LORD, but the LORD was not in the wind; and after the wind an earthquake, but the LORD was not in the earthquake; and after the earthquake a fire, but the LORD was not in the fire; and after the fire a still small voice.
We've all looked for a big sign and wound up with a still, small voice, haven't we? And I think we've all had times when we've been "done" and wanted to curl up in a cave. Elijah performed God's miracles but in the details of his life he is more like us than we might think.

Elijah raises the widow's son, Julius Schnorr von Carolsfeld, 1851-60

Lights on the Riverwalk

Lights on the Riverwalk, San Antonio (2012),
with permission from Jason Merlo Photography

 

Wednesday, December 20, 2023

Jesse Tree - Day 14: David

I last published these Jesse Tree posts in 2019. I want to revisit them this Advent so you're coming along for the ride!

The Jesse Tree helps us prepare for Christ's coming by studying His roots and Salvation History. 

Jesse Trees follow the same general outline but I've found they are widely varied in some of the details. Some may have one day for Moses, others may spend 4 days on different aspects of his life. I'll be following the basic outline but, therefore, using my own discretion in a few spots.

Day 14: David

Symbols: shepherd's crook, harp, slingshot, 6-pointed star

Michelangelo, David and Goliath, 1509

David began as a shepherd, the youngest of the family, and from Bethlehem. When I read his story in the Bible his humanity becomes so clear. He is so often the best of what we hope from humanity. And he also is often the worst. His most famous descendant, Jesus, was also from Bethlehem and is our shepherd.

“I am the good shepherd, and I know mine and mine know me, just as the Father knows me and I know the Father; and I will lay down my life for the sheep.”(John 10:14, 15)

David is anointed king by Samuel, Anonymous