Monday, May 24, 2021

News of the World — in print and on screen

In the wake of the Civil War, Captain Jefferson Kyle Kidd travels through northern Texas, giving live readings from newspapers to paying audiences hungry for news of the world. He is offered a $50 gold piece to deliver a young orphan to her relatives in San Antonio. She had been raised by the Kiowa raiders who killed her family and is completely unfamiliar with white culture. Their 400-mile journey south through unsettled territory and unforgiving terrain proves difficult and at times dangerous.
I read this because my daughter, Hannah, recommended it. I don't know what I expected but it wasn't to be captivated, which is what happened. More than anything it put me in mind of True Grit. Which means I loved it for reasons that I can't really put my finger on.

Having seen the movie, I realized that the book was better plotted and written than I realized. I am going to listen to it soon, so I'll have a "news of the world" experience of having Grover Gardner tell it to me.


This was interesting because they did a pretty good job of telling the story. Not as good as the book but good enough in its own way. There were some changes of motivation which did not make as much sense and left one family member saying, "Why on earth does he do that?" And there were some added bits which I didn't mind but which were obviously there to be sure we understood the modern lessons  on a few things.  I did enjoy the "fake news" section which was added on but felt true to the original story.

Overall good with some great acting and beautiful cinematography. More than anything I wish the director hadn't gone for such dark lighting, with nights being very gloomy and even the brightest day somehow not being that bright. I get it. This is a serious story. You can lighten things up so we can see and we will still know the main characters are wrestling with serious personal issues.

The glory of nature

Logan, Utah. Taken by Scott Danielson

Friday, May 14, 2021

A supremely child-centered faith

Throughout history, Jews were called on to treasure children. Our entire value system is built on it. Our citadels are schools, our passion, education, and our greatest heroes, teachers. The seder service on Passover opens with questions asked by a child. On the first day of the New Year, we read not about the creation of the universe but about the birth of a child — Isaac to Sarah, Samuel to Hannah. Ours is a supremely child-centered faith.

That is why, at the dawn of Jewish time, God put Abraham and Sarah through these trials — the long wait, the unmet hope, the binding itself — so that neither they nor their descendants would ever take children for granted. Every child is a miracle. Being a parent is the closest we get to God — bringing life into being through an act of love.
Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation: Genesis

Yellow-winged darter

Yellow-winged darter, Сергій Мірошник

Thursday, May 13, 2021

The Greatest Expression of Faith in a God We Cannot See, But Only Hear

I began by pointing out that the Torah was a text intended to be read aloud and listened to. It is the single greatest expression of faith in a God we cannot see, but only hear. Judaism is supremely a religion of the ear, unlike all other ancient civilizations, which were cultures of the eye. This is more than a metaphysical fact. It is a moral one as well. In Judaism the highest spiritual gift is the ability to listen — not only to the voice of God, but also to the cry of other people, the sigh of the por, the weak, the lonely, the neglects and, yes, sometimes the un- or less-loved. That is one of the meanings of the great command Shema Yisrael, "Listen, O Israel." ...
Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation: Genesis

Kammer Castle

Gustav Klimt, Schloss Kammer in the Attersee IV, 1910
via Arts Everyday Living
 

Wednesday, May 12, 2021

Psalm 16 — Faithfulness to the Lord

Psalm 16 reveals [the Savior's] resurrection from the dead.
Athanasius, On the Interpretation of the Psalms

Athanasius's statement above might seem surprising but the early Church Fathers (and many others since then) routinely read the psalms to see how Christ was revealed in them. In that sense, we go back to Jesus' appearance on the road to Emmaus where he describes to the two disciples everything that refers to him in the scriptures (Luke 24:13-35). This is possibly my favorite resurrection story. I love thinking of Jesus conducting that Bible study.

Taking their cue from Jesus himself, then, the early Church began looking at where scripture talked about the Messiah. They found a lot to talk about in the psalms. Read the psalm, thinking of Jesus speaking to God the Father.

A singing and dancing David leads the Ark of the Covenant, Pieter van Lint

This is surely the purest way to approach God, with complete trust. Can we do it? We have Jesus as our example so we know that even when things don't look like they are working out right, God has a bigger plan than we can imagine.

16:5. The Lord is a Chosen Portion

I Love You, Lord, St. Augustine: [The psalmist is saying] "O Lord, why give me some other inheritance? Whatever you give, it isn't worth much. You be my inheritance; I love you, I love you with all I am, with all my heart, with all my soul, with all my mind I love you. What can it mean to me, anything you give me apart from yourself?" That is to love God freely, to hope in God for God, to hasten to be filled with God, to be satisfied with him. He, after all, is enough for you: apart from him, nothing is enough for you. Sermon 334.3

Psalms 1-50 (Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture)

Sources are here and an index of psalm posts is here


Tuesday, May 11, 2021

A Movie You Might Have Missed #41: Spinning Plates

It's been 11 years since I began this series highlighting movies I wished more people knew about. I'm rerunning it from the beginning because I still think these are movies you might have missed.

It's not what you cook. It's why.

This was a fascinating comparison of three very different restaurants - one high concept where the chef is like an artist, one Iowa restaurant that holds the community together, and one Mexican restaurant where the family has placed their hopes for a better life on its success. The flow is masterful between the places as their stories progress and we get to know the main restauranteurs.

It was also interesting in that none of these were about going somewhere to get a bite to eat. All these places were the focus of hopes, dreams, and fulfillment on an entirely different plane than mere sustenance. It compares well with Jiro Dreams of Sushi and, in fact, I liked it better.

We found ourselves afterward in terms of our own business, our own hopes and dreams, and our own lives. Highly recommended.

Monday, May 10, 2021

Bianca degli Utili Maselli and six of her children

Portrait of Bianca degli Utili Maselli and six of her children,
by Lavinia Fontana, c. 1600s.
Via J.R.'s Art Place

The tea-party, an extraordinary meal

Another novelty is the tea-party, an extraordinary meal in that, being offered to persons that have already dined well, it supposes neither appetite nor thirst, and has no object but distraction, no basis but delicate enjoyment.
Jean-Anthelme Brillat-Savarin, The Physiology of Taste

Friday, May 7, 2021

Genesis is truth as story

Genesis is Judaism's foundational work, a philosophy of the human condition under the sovereignty of God.

This is a difficult point to understand, because there is no other book quite like it. It is not myth. It is not history in the conventional sense, a mere recording of events. Nor is it theology. Genesis is less about God than about human beings and their relationship with god. the theology is almost always implicit rather than explicit. What Genesis is, in fact, is philosophy written in a deliberately non-philosophical way. ... To put it at its simplest: philosophy is truth as system. Genesis is truth as story. It is a unique work, philosophy in the narrative mode ...

Judaism is about the democratization of holiness, the creation of a whole society in which everyone will have access to religious knowledge. Hence the importance of stories which everyone can understand.

Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation: Genesis

Just So Stories

1912 Edition

Thursday, May 6, 2021

Garden Snail

Garden Snail, N Puttapipat Illustration

Why was man created last?

As the rabbis put it: "Why was man created last? In order to say, if he is worthy, all creation was made for you; but if he is unworthy, he is told, even a gnat preceded you."
Jonathan Sacks, Covenant & Conversation: Genesis

Wednesday, May 5, 2021

Psalm 15 — Who May Dwell with God?

If you wish to learn what sort of person is a citizen of the kingdom of heaven, sing Psalm 15.
Athanasius, On the Interpretation of the Psalms

No other sources this week, just my own thought about this immediately following Psalm 14. That psalm told of all the evil done by those who don't believe God exists. This psalm seems to act as a counterpoint by defining who is righteous enough to dwell with God. The line items seem to match up pretty well with the ones we were given before in Psalm 14. 

 We wind up with a concise and well defined list of traits for those who need not fear to enter God's presence. This seems simple but is well worth reflecting upon. I especially like the qualifying phrase added after "who keeps his oath" — "even when it hurts." I think that might apply to the other characteristics also.

David Composing the Psalms, Paris Psalter, 10th century

Sources are here and an index of psalm posts is here

 

Tuesday, May 4, 2021

"How shall we live?" — Genesis: The Book of Beginnings by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks

Each week, synagogues around the world read a section from the Torah (the five books of Moses). The  cycle begins with Genesis and ends with the last verses of Deuteronomy 12 months later. The Covenant & Conversation series has essays commenting on each of the weekly readings. 

These essays are by Rabbi Jonathan Sacks who was the Chief Rabbi of the U.K. for some 20 years. I'd read his editorials occasionally in the Wall Street Journal and always found them insightful, inspirational, and down to earth. When I discovered he'd done this series I began at the beginning with Genesis. What I found was a work of genius.

These essays have the same easy style I remembered while giving indepth, brilliant, compassionate commentary that often surprised me and sometimes changed my whole perspective on a Biblical person or their actions. Sacks is good at comparing ancient and modern worldviews. This not only clarifies Biblical context but often shows just how different our current ideas are. These are stories about people and Sacks never forgets that. He looks at what Torah is showing us that is the same not only in those ancient times, but in our own lives. After all, the word of God is eternal, applying to all time and all people.

I learned new ways of looking deeper at familiar stories such as when Isaac is tricked into giving his blessing to Jacob instead of Esau. I found deeper sympathy and new insights into lesser characters. Who knew she was not only crafty but also tactful? Or that Judah's encounter with Tamar led to a life-changing realization that helped him pass Joseph's test when the brothers all go to Egypt seeking grain? I already loved Tamar but now I have more sympathy and admiration for Judah's growth.

There is much here that resonates with the Catholic soul, simply because the Jews are our elder brothers in the faith. However, a Christian reading these essays will be sharply reminded that there is a Jewish way of thinking about the first five books of the Bible, and, indeed, about God and worship, which is particular to the Jewish people. That is a real cultural wake up call and one that I found sometimes jerking me to the realization that this is different. The thinking, the response to God and His call, the way of dealing with other people — it can be very different, while still being anchored in our common knowledge of the one, personal God.

A quick example is that I was surprised by the Jewish custom of reading Torah every year. Just like us! No, I realized. We're just like them. The first Christians were Jewish and I am well used to finding parts of Catholic liturgy that reflect they were patterned after those Christians' original faith. That was an easy mental adjustment, one that left me happy at another proof of our family ties.

Here are a few of the themes emphasized as being core parts of Judaism, which surprised me.

  •  Love of words and language, both as forms of worship and of what make us human.
  • Treasuring children. "Ours is a supremely child-centered faith" says Sacks.
  • God making space so that people can exercise free will and make mistakes.
  • The importance of the land God gave them, of Israel.
  • The Torah is meant to be heard, not read silently. "Judaism is supremely a religion of the ear, unlike all other ancient civilizations..." says Sacks.
  • The necessity of the struggle to do God's will and of going one step more than we are asked.

These might seem like no brainers, reading this list. It's not that Catholicism doesn't have these elements but they don't define us the way that Sacks made clear they define the Jewish people. I found myself understanding a little better their pride at their indestructibility, the ancientness of their faith, and their role as God's chosen people.

There is a fair amount of midrash considered throughout. Midrash is textual study and interpretation of scripture that uses questions, examines what is left unsaid, and fills in with their own stories to form a running commentary. I'm not crazy about midrash as it can range far afield sometimes. I'm not Jewish so perhaps that is understandable. Sacks sometimes includes midrash in order to keep following the logical train of thought and sometimes so that he can introduce a different interpretation.

Quibbles about midrash aside, this is a work of genius. Highly recommended.

Note: A few excerpts are shared here.

Napoleon Bonaparte

Napoléon Bonaparte by Andrea Appiani
Since I'm reading Les Miserables right now and there are many characters who continually define themselves and others by their support (or lack thereof) for Napoleon, this hit me just right when I came across it.

Monday, May 3, 2021

A Sure Foundation for a Beautiful Friendship

There is no surer foundation for a beautiful friendship than a mutual taste in literature.
P.G. Wodehouse

Friday, April 30, 2021

A Spiral Staircase Inside One of the Vatican Museums

A spiral staircase inside one of the Vatican Museums

Well Said: The Riddle of Fiction

The riddle of fiction comes to this: Evolution is ruthlessly utilitarian. How has the seeming luxury of fiction not been eliminated from human life?
Jonathan Gottschal, The Storytelling Animal
Jonathan Gottschall measures everything against evolution, which is the only measure he really trusts for giving scientific answers about people and story. Therefore, he isn't able to answer some of the questions he poses in his book because some things just can't be measured by science. (It's still an interesting book. You don't have to answer every question all the time.)

That was what made it entertaining when, some time later in his books, he inadvertently answered the above question with the conclusion that I, as a Catholic, already knew.
Why do stories cluster around a few big themes, and why do they hew so closely to problem structure? Why are stories this way instead of all the other ways they could be? I think that problem structure reveals a major function of storytelling. It suggests that the human mind was shaped for story, so that it could be shaped by story.
Jonathan Gottschal, The Storytelling Animal
Yep.